Civ 4 caste system reddit . 90. Maybe not in religious institutions but certainly in society. So this is not only detrimental for the so called lower caste but also the high caste . Is karma hereditary? Varna system was based on your karma. Dominant castes in India defines her caste system not the Varna system. In Civ 4 especially with the vassal system- you'd often have spheres of influence forming and such. The caste system itself is not on use at all. If your parents are nobility, then you are as well. You could study it if you are interested. A GS can bulb +1600 beakers, which means you can use one to bulb Philosophy, Paper or 1/2 Education. i believe the caste system is deprecated, but this is a theoretical question, so we can cover India 100 years ago. There's caste system within Sikhs. With the disappearance of many occupations due to technology, that has change. Its 3d style has a great charm which (for civ games) still holds up imo. But civ 4 more simple yet "theres more than meets the eye" approach is also great. The caste system is a bit of a oversimplified shorthand for the ethno-religous inter-relationships of the Indian subcontinent over thousands of years of history. He mentioned about the notion of pollution and purity attached with Indian caste system. They are based on past KarmA and dictate things in your life. Another good reason to run Caste btw. This city is not to make anything but grow great people. I may get downvoted for this, but there are many aspects of Indian life that don't really have anything to do with the caste system. In the past, each caste was associated with a distinct traditional occupation, and a caste might be divided into subcastes in keeping with differences in Oh I agree that the Indian caste system is super fucked up, I'm just saying that it shouldn't be a specific provision -- in my view it should be incorporated into a general class-based protection, or perhaps also falling under religious discrimination since the caste system is rooted in their religion originally. In fact, it was western colonization that caused this bastardization of the caste system. are that the Merchant-Slots are "cheaper" , because Markets and Grocers are very expensive. You're absolutely right that the word caste was introduced by them, and the varna system was the system that was prevalent in India, and yes its origins were on the basis of the work you did, and it was fluid in nature. Purity of caste is very important. 28 votes, 14 comments. The question is how those differences are different from place to place. Yes you want food and production in some moderation but for a huge part of Aug 12, 2011 · Caste system is a luxury that I never have the pop points to afford. These two castes make up the Low Caste Tier. The British had done some pretty abhorrent things in India, but let's not blame them for the caste system as well. During the pre-early modern era, with different empires rising to power and then into the Muslim conquest, the caste system was brought back. Nair is technically a Shudra caste but one of the most dominant caste in Kerala with powerful people and lot of wealth. So the more gold commerce a city produces, the more can be turned into research. Civ 5 and Civ 6 have more overall game synergy which for sure makes more interesting playstyles and additive. When you can construct a new building type that will benefit what the city is specialized in, you momentarily focus on production to get it done and then shift the citizens back to specialists. He used the oracle free tech to get code of laws which let him run caste system. Wikipedia page dedicated to the Topic "Caste system in India" From the same page. Faxian probably didn't notice the caste system because he spent most of his time in monasteries and in royal areas as well as being more nomadic and not speaking the language as well. Hi, Can someone educate me deeply about the cast system in India especially on my below mental conflicts and confusions. The British took advantage of this and added masala to the Manusmriti to make the varna system appear as a caste system which discriminates people from birth. " Something that has been entrenched firmly in this land and flows in the very blood of people here, cannot be removed instantly. Caste system is something that was established in indian subcontinent for atleast 1000 years Constitution of India had abolished caste system, and gives special powers to state to ensure its enforcement. Note that neither of these rely on cottages either, so they’re resistant to bombing/missiles. However, the vast majority of Hindus still have a strong caste identity. Unless males are, in essence, used as breed stock. Oct 18, 2007 · When you expand too quickly and the economy in a mess (frequently after an early rush), Caste system allows you to run merchants without markets, which are actually quite costly to build, so you can keep your economy afloat. It's the oldest text which presents the caste system as heriditary, with strict prohibition of intermarriages across caste lines. 28 votes, 70 comments. Generate some great merchants and use them for trade missions. Yes caste system still exists; but the extent of its influence has considerably reduced. Some Jatis served as Royals, Soldiers, Village heads, cultivators, servants of royals etc historically or during the same period. You can read Louis Dumount in this aspect. I love flood plains-packed cities, they're amazing for representation/caste system strategies, but they are hard to manage. 11 hammers Jun 7, 2001 · I love caste system civic. Then later it evolved and become as it was 30 years back. The influence of caste right now is at its lowest as the system of specific caste doing only specific jobs has completely fallen apart. So you could be a theocratic democracy, or a socialist republic, or a pacifist police state with a caste system, so that was fun. It is funny and sad how I, an apparent upper caste (Brahmin), have faced casteism from certain Brahmin families in the area since I come from a city that doesn't adhere to the caste-system and married a Muslim woman and serve rare NY strip steaks on family dinners :D. Epsilon- Epsilons are the lowest ranking class in the caste system. It has now mostly become political and social structure. So, you can change your varna. I only learned very late into my civ4 experience the viability of an espionage-based economy through which you can steal tech more efficiently than you can research it. GS Strategy - use Caste system + Pacifism (if possible) + NE (if possible) to generate GS points. Nope. In Pakistan caste is synonymous for tribe name. com We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. The Slave caste is largely a punishment caste made up of criminals, debtors who have sold themselves, those captured from conquered lands, and those the emperor wants to make an example of. Mom's family disowned her and dad's family always viewed her with apprehension. Nowadays individuals might marry in a different subcaste of their own caste, and sometimes in a different, though cognate, caste; but marriages without consideration of caste are still rare. Although Sikhs carry the caste bias as well today In the mid-game, post Biology and Communism, with Caste System and all the techs that upgrade Workshop output, Farms + Workshops are better than immature Cottages and competitive with Towns (I wouldn't bulldoze Towns and maybe Villages for Workshops unless I am in "turn off all research" mode - e. Some countries still have the categories for census reasons and stuff but the only legacy it really has is with relation to the mestizo/pardo self identified people. The caste system as described in the Manusmriti is very different from the one that Al beruni seems to be describing. Finally, the best example of all this are Sikhs. But the social status structure that led to caste system is. There are some fantastic combos hidden in there - in particular, representation + caste system + pacifism is a combo that I remember for being powerful. It's important to keep expanding and grabbing up resources, which helps both health and happiness. If your parents are street-cleaners, then so are you. fandom. Slavery converts food to hammers at a fairly decent rate. g. 44K subscribers in the sexandthecity community. Originally, it was more of a guild system, where occupations stuck together, and since many fathers trained their sons in the profession, it naturally became sort of birth based. true. Social class is primarily social and Maybe I've just been lucky but I've worked with a vast majority of both men and women from India across 3 jobs and never experienced the caste system or racism amongst themselves or anyone else. The Varnashram(popularly known as the Caste system) is absolutely by birth. It's found in one of the principal Upanishads of Hinduism - Chandogya Upanishad. Below all of them, outside the caste system, are the Verkahn, the Outcasts. However, I I've seen this happen quite a few times on Reddit and other places too: non-Indians somehow equating all Indian problems with the caste system. Two huge indicators of how strong the caste system still is: Whitening creams (to make your skin pale because pale skin = no manual labour = high caste = desirable); and that in marriage personals in the newpaper, even Christian Indians will list their pre-conversion caste - so that Brahmin Christians are more desirable than lower-caste The failgold system in civ4 means every wonder has to compete with 'what if I didn't finish this and just got a cash payout'? I think a lot of the weaker wonders don't clear this bar- I'm curious where you'd draw the line. Well a little bit of background, my parents have a mixed caste marriage, mom's high caste, dad's low caste. The main castes in AP are Kapus, Kammas, Reddys, Velama(more in Telangana), Mala, Brahmins, others. Most of them are some of the smartest people I've worked with. Just basic example - landowner ( upper caste ) call all the shots and remain in power against the poor farmers ( lower caste) who works on his fields even though they are much higher in number but lower in power and money . Within that caste there will be levels in which determines your wealth and worth to society. As per the Jajamani system, each caste had the “right” to participate in certain ceremonies and festivals. I love the enthusiasm of the kids here - "REMOVE the caste system. " But caste was rigid and entrenched since around 2000 years ago, at the very least, if not before. In india their is whole system based on their caste system. According to the New Testament (the books written about Jesus' life and the early church up through a handful of decades after Jesus left the world), there was some heavy debate in the early church about how the relationship between Jews and non-Jews was supposed to work--seeing as Christianity claims to be a continuation/perfected version/next step of the Jewish religion--but the people Chapter 4, verse 13 is where Krishna refers directly to varna (which was the origin of the caste system in India). Then came civ 5 and I while the game was ok and i still play it occasionally, I think the biggest damage it did to the series was make the meta into "sitting in a corner with 4-5 cities outputting science. Caste system has been enshrined and made into bigger than it is. Now, two things: Shudra(lowest caste) is from the feet and culturally, feet is inauspicious in Hindu culture. How government works in 4 is more interesting. The caste system was merely the name that the British assigned to the system of social organisation that they observed in India. In fact, Hinduism as we know it today took shape in the 200 BC to 300AD period which is much later. Now you should designate a city a "great person farm", ideally a city with lots of food and little else. . The fact many people in modern times don't following the caste system correctly, isn't the fault of the caste system. Jan 13, 2010 · Four ways to use well Caste system: 1. The caste system is very much cultural not just religious. Caste system is thriving as always in Tamil Nadu. It's a somewhere in-between caste, let's say a middle caste. Learn the social engineering table. You could be the son of a Brahmin but if you were good at, say fighting, and you went ahead and got into the army, you would be a kshatriya. If you play by the rules, you prosper within your caste, and if you don't, then you lose your caste and become an untouchable- an outcaste. Caste System is fantastic for running a ton of Scientists to rush out multiple Great People (especially during a Golden Age boom, where people will even starve their cities to pop out a lot of GP). Universal Suffrage/Vassalage/Caste System/State Property/Organized Religion (or Free Religion) is another powerhouse. But neither of them have the caste system. People are mad at me on Reddit because I said I support the caste system. Try to make sure you have all necessary buildings up before switching to Caste System. The trifunctional hypothesis of prehistoric Proto-Indo-European society postulates a tripartite ideology ("idéologie tripartite") reflected in the existence of three classes or castes—priests, warriors, and commoners (farmers or tradesmen)—corresponding to the three functions of the sacral, the martial and the economic, respectively. By: Rohinton Mistry | 603 pages | Published: 1995 | Popular Shelves: fiction, india, historical-fiction, book-club, favourites | Search "A Fine Balance" With a compassionate realism and narrative sweep that recall the work of Charles Dickens, this magnificent novel captures all the cruelty and corruption, dignity and heroism, of India. It's the laziest and very efficient way to play that is agnostic of available resources, and will be viable even on Deity level. It finds that a significant degree of mobility was to be seen in this society, and neither at the individual nor at the corporate level was there an acceptance of an immutable caste system and social ranking. Many dominant castes in Tamilnadu like Thevar etc. In Civ 3, you could just be a monarchy or democracy or whatever, in Civ 4 you can mix and match policies across 5 different categories. If your parents are merchants, that's what you are. This will also to an extent depend on your leader's traits. So I think I am able to reason it out in both view points. At least, it wasn't strictly adhered to. Caste system was actually first implemented on social status. Deltas wear the color khaki. What you have is more a class system than a caste one. and if a higher-caste employee finds their way into management it's definitely not unheard of to quietly The caste system in India has its origins in ancient India, and was transformed by various ruling elites in medieval, early-modern, and modern India, especially the Mughal Empire and the British Raj. The subreddit to discuss anything related to the TV show Sex and the City. It is a misrepresentation of the varna system for personal benefit. See full list on civilization. Under the Varna section, the article mentions that it is a system consisting of four classes. Oct 26, 2005 · But the other 10-20% I run caste system in a combo with pacifism to extreme-produce GP´s (GS and/or GM´s) I don´t think they rival, I would rather say they work very well together (slavery to produce and build, caste-system to get GP´s) because a combo of productivity and GP production (GS = lightbulbing and GM = money) is a good way to go Tech to CoL through currency. But it is far from the only caste system and it is not so different as is usually supposed. The use of representation, bureaucracy and especially the caste system is encouraged when you play in this fashion. As you may know, the Hindu caste system governs everything about their lives. The caste system used to simply be something like the class system we have in modern societies. The text translates to: The four divisions of human order were created by me according to differences in quality, activities and aptitude. Like every religion and philosophy, there are things that need interpretation. I'm Hindu, and to clarify I do not mean caste discrimination. Caste system can be useful - unlimited scientists/merchants for science/money and great people (and artists - for city radius expansion). Caste system is social hierarchy where top 10-15% fools the rest for their own advantage. Being born in a high caste did not mean a person was of a higher spiritual status, which was contrary to the view of the brahmins. The caste system consists of two different concepts, varna and jati, which may be regarded as different levels of analysis. The caste system is thousands of years old and is deeply ingrained into indian society. Wikipedia page dedicated to the topic "Caste System in India" From the same Wikipedia page. But caste still plays a major part in society as for majority of people it is important to marry within their own caste. The Buddha did not dispute how society structured itself though. The caste system is one where one's parentage determines one's place in society. They are the worst of the worst. a class one. And as corrupt as the caste system has become, isn't any different than the class system in any modern western country. are Shudra in 4 varna system. To say that it was somehow shaped or manufactured by the British would be to ignore the previous 3000 years of history which shaped the caste system which the British came into contact with in the 17th and 18th centuries. The following papers shed light on caste endogamy and male driven mixing patterns in Indo-Aryan/Rig Vedic society. You can change your karma. General castes today marry each other if other factors match like social status. It's the most efficient way to beeline Liberalism. (Its hard to explain to Americans because they themselves had somewhat been subject to culturally reappropriated propaganda, where all European immigrants Anyway, I think we can make a case for the caste system entering in the late vedic era and then becoming more and more rigid up until the early Gupta period. Think different classes in RPGs. But this could also be coz caste difference in the older days meant economic differences too. Most of the time, I am willing to put up with that extra unhappy faces in each city if that's what must be done to reap the benefits of this caste civic. With time caste got divided into many subcastes with restricted mobility and Increasing hierarchy in the system. Caste system- better workers and better specialists for the cost of a manageable happiness penalty. 2. People can and do change their social class. Agrarianism- I feel like I use this incorrectly because it makes me compulsively build farms only on grassland. The Manusmriti entrenches and solidifies the caste system. If you look at whom the caste system benefits the most (the Brahmins), you can see how such changes protect the Brahmin turf. ) Each specialist provides +3bpt and +2 scientist GPP/turn, which is on par with working a financial coast plus the GPP. " This is from Rig Veda 10. Caste system was in its initial form was a way to segregate professions but over the centuries it has became a mechanism of oppression which is milked by the politicians , media and the other participants of this ecosystem. Really nice for altar victory to give you a bit of extra value for the priests. It exists, whether your parents are from Punjab, Gujarat, Maharashtra or elsewhere it comes up. The caste system is basically just a way that the vedas used to sort people into different classes. In fact, not just Hindus, but all communities in India have a caste identity, including those following Abrahamic faiths such as Islam and Christianity. This exercise becomes necessary to do away with the notion that the rigid caste boundaries as we understand them, were a recent Hindu Caste Influence. The caste system did not simply allocate jobs, it also defined the hierarchy of social precedence. As a rule, once you've figured out how you're going to grow your economy (either farms and caste system or cottages, play the map with this to a degree - if you have a ton of food, run specialists. How was the Caste system in India before Britishers, is it Britishers who labeled the 100s of caste name? I have heard that at that time people would change caste, but it is not clear if the higher caste were moved to lower Emancipation's growth to cottages won't do much for you, while caste system is an absolute must. Caste has a religious justification and explanation. Sep 20, 2009 · 2) If this is your best GP farm, then aim to build National Epic before switching to Caste System. So just blaming it on society is not correct. They are also loggers. Jan 18, 2007 · workshop : -1 (unless under State Property) +2 +4 (with Caste System & Chemistry) In the modern era, I'm typically running 2 kinds of economy : (1) Either Cottage spam (w/ Free Speech & usually Free Market, although State Property is possible) (2) Either State Property + Caste System In case (2), with all techs enabled Farm -> Workshop -2 + 4 The caste system almost certainly went through various phases of relative rigidity and flexibility. There isn't supposed to be intermarriage between the castes, either, though among the middle "tier" they're quite loose with this. But sadly, youngsters too are favouring it. The caste system is not much relevant now. Actually, the thing is, the caste system was widely in disuse post-Buddhism. Their jobs are more simple mentally, but more physical. Whereas in civ5 you want food to grow your city's to colossal sizes and science buildings to increase research, in civ 4 any gold commerce a city earns is turned into what's in the top left. The only time I've used it is one game where I was for a time at -100 gold/turn at 0% research after conquering all of Europe with immortals. But because some words are same in both the countries which defines different things people get misguided because of that. Everything depends upon your karma ultimately. In relation to the caste system being used as a manner of organizing worldly society, I am unaware of him saying anything against it. So my main concern now is that you’ve answered almost every concern with (paraphrased) “the nobility arbitrarily step in”. 5 populations worth of output (at Marathon) that's a conversion of 1 food for 1. I wouldn't worry too much about it, if the caste system was only favoured by older people. Slavery is a system for resource conversion, it is no different than specialists, wealth/research/culture, wonder gold, and a few others. Trifunctional Hypothesis. I find using it to turn every specialist in every city Merchants. The "meta" is to play State Property + Caste System with Workshops until the cows come home, which bans you from using Corporations. Could be that HR was really strict at those companies so they had to walk on eggshells. Once you hit Code of Laws, you can recruit much more specialists by selecting Caste System, but you still want scientists. Your status is determined at birth, and there's nothing Caste System eliminates the restrictions for item 3, but conflicts with Slavery as well as other labor civics. People who compare caste to social class see a few things that make it different. It’s hard to explain this to Americans, especially white Americans but the caste system is a remnant of time before the British invaded, when kings and queens and princes ruled the land. The . I usually put a 10% into culture to counteract it (most of your science doesn't come from there anyways). You can set up your type of ruler, your economy, your legal system, your religion and one more independently of each other. Kanchi Shankaracharya has a detailed discussion on the caste system in his book "Hindu Dharma". Slavery wouldn't help at that point. A Fine Balance. you're born into your caste, and it does not change. You might run into hapiness issues later on if all other civs adopt emancipation. Class systems can have hereditary aspects, but are far less limited. It is what you are born to. The British then banned Gurukuls and introduced their Macauly system of education, banned temple gatherings and basically isolated Indian Hindus of those days. "Delta- Deltas are the fourth ranking class system. 'The caste system was highly complex, with many intricate strands which linked the social groups with their economic base. Al beruni's writings are not indicative of the nature of the caste system in the eighteenth century. 3) Use a Golden Age as your entry point into Caste System, and emphasize running more specialists during the Golden Age, rather than before. This may later become critical if Emancipation is adopted by another civ, since the unhappiness generated by failing to adopt Emancipation can be a serious drain on productivity. Sikhism was in many ways a response against the caste system. I never had much affinity for caste system, usually preferring the accelerated and cheaper land development offered by serfdom. For artists, writers, gamemasters, musicians, programmers, philosophers and scientists alike! The creation of new worlds and new universes has long been a key element of speculative fiction, from the fantasy works of Tolkien and Le Guin, to the science-fiction universes of Delany and Asimov, to the tabletop realm of Gygax and Barker, and beyond. That made families to follow select few professions. Historically oppressed castes have been given affirmative action with reservation in all public institutions and legislative assemblies Apr 8, 2007 · Apart from that, Caste + Pacifism are very nice in Golden Ages and the Border-pops from Artist-specialists are the easiest ever, so with being SPI, one might want to switch to Caste only to not build some Monuments ^^ . Say a 2 pop whip from 5 to 3 is 81 food for 90 hammers + . That can be fine, but nobles aren’t untouchable; if your society seems stable, but arbitrary, savvy readers at least will question how it’s stable, and why the nobility aren’t getting anything from: plebeian strikes (a real event where the plebs would leave The caste system is not anywhere as embedded as western critical media portrays it. In my book so far (aka 7 sentences) people find their soulmates by matching tattoos so I am thinking of a caste system that is a caste within a caste. It wasn't decided by birth but by profession. I don't know the best way to deal with. As to the caste system being a dying belief in India, that is true of some circles. 12. Caste system let him run merchant specialists and since gandhi is philosophical it doesn't take very long to get two great merchants up and running. Hindu or Sikh. There will be the castes that include the people who've found their soulmates. They complete construction and factory jobs. Over the years, as the population grew, the caste system outgrew its need but the people (especially the beneficiaries of the caste system) never ditched it. I don't come from an upper caste or a lower caste here in India. Hence the caste system flourished. In fact, I love it so much that I see nothing good that can come out of the emancipation civic. (except for the rare time Engineers are needed for production in island cities) The gold from all the Merchants allows me to run the slider @ 80%+ without the need to run Wealth and the great Merchants are especially useful both for a large lump sum of gold instantly but to help Making females without magical ability the lowest caste. Being in a different caste means you have different DharmA and responsibilities. As i found in various sources couples must be from the same caste level to be able to marry. The Labor civic tree has exactly two strong options - Slavery and Caste System. If anything Hinduism codified the evil of castes system which is the only reason it exists even after thousands of years. Also I miss the individual era themes. I am a Punjabi Hindu and I know lots of Sikhs. While many indo canadians in big hubs in Canada are Punjabi & Sikh (the two aren’t mutually exclusive), the reality is castism shapes a big part of subtle undertones and overt interactions within families and communit Posted by u/RisenSteam - 6 votes and 27 comments In a practical sense, “Varna” as a political caste system was never implemented by any rulers. Doesn't everyone have a surname everywhere? :) First, I'm no expert, so if anyone has any expertise, I defer to them. Especially in private businesses and therefore IT workplace. There are certain jobs reserved for the elite castes, and certain jobs reserved for the lowest rung. If your parents were of a caste- so are you! Also tends to be much less intermarriage (often to the point of illegality) in a caste system vs. It is still stuck in Stone Age when it comes to caste-based social hierarchy. People have misused this to make jati hereditary. Everyone accepted that the purpose of life is to attain Moksha and not to amass money and live in comfort. In the middle ranges, the hierarchy was somewhat ambiguous, but the unequal status of untouchables was sharply demarcated by barriers of ritual impurity. The caste system was originally formed to organize the society so that everyone had a part to play and the society doesn't fall because some of its jobs were being neglected. Resistance against the caste system has been brewing in different forms for hundreds of years. Not only does currency give you a passive bonus to trade routes, but Caste System allows an arbitrary number of scientists (and artistes and merchants. The Tamil are some of the least understood ethnic groups out there, but they take great pride in having newspapers printed today in one of the worlds first written languages. Most of the kiddos here are not aware how much we have come towards caste equalization in the last 50 years, when in many parts of the country Dalits were not even allowed to walk p India's caste system is, of course, unique in the way all national institutions are unique. Caste discrimination is a real thing in workplaces with a lot of employees from India, even though the caste system was officially abolished over there, many employees from higher castes discriminate against employees from lower castes. There were similar and contemporary systems in China, Korea, Japan, pre-Christian Igbo and Mande societies And as for historical precedent, there are even more. It gave the Hindus guilds and protected occupations, allowing for trade. They occupy a higher place in the caste system for their magic power and rarity (and necessity to continue the species) and they can influence who gets to be in charge, but lack direct power on their own. Caste system in India: According to Wikipedia. Caste system in India and Pakistan is not the same at all. The state is only progressive in religious equality, gender equality, etc. They are less intelligent than the Alphas, Betas, and Gammas. Don’t mix Varnas with caste system in India. It isn't exactly against people or supporting inequality Aug 4, 2009 · I always go into Caste if I'm gonna warmonger. cgeis cuqyfg gvhkq omcjj tmvbmr ede hrtzbuxv hburk psu ceerwub