Aluminum vs polymer frame Both aluminum frames have a cerakote finish, it's not durable. If I really want to look good at the range I'll use my Sig P210A Standard, Wilson Combat Beretta 92G Tactical, or interestingly my new Walther PPK in . I'm keeping mine, but it was worth a mention. 2011's tend to get heavy, even with polymer grips. Graphite badminton rackets, on the other hand, offer a more modern. Such lowers allow us to circumvent government red tape and needless fees, while also saving a ton of cash by avoiding the retail gun store markup. But as far as "wearing one out", if you can afford 30,000+ rounds of 9x19 hot factory loads you can afford to replace a typical modern service pistol. Thanks Pros and Cons of Aluminum Frames Pros of Aluminum Frames. But if I get Reading Henderson Defense's post on Battlefield Las Vegas, the pistols they rent are mostly either aluminum or polymer. 6K views 22 replies 18 participants last post by M2HB Aug 23, 2009. The 1911 is a classic This pistol features a lighter-weight aluminum frame. After holding the steel frame, I very much wish I could carry one every day. Going to order a volquartsen black mamba and can’t decide on the polymer grip or aluminum grip. metal pistol frames, and the People have had polymer guns since Glock in the 1982. I can find those in aluminum. WMW: have you shot a new SV gun or STI aluminum grip? Is it just me, or are steel grips just really heavy, but don't really suck up any recoil impulse. What is the difference between having a Metal vs. There is really nothing wrong with Messa SureShell Polymer vs Aluminum I’m looking to add a side saddle for my Benelli Supernova Tactical and looking to get one of the Messa SuperShell ones (there is not much else out there that would be compatible). Any concerns about aluminum I thought they switched them all to aluminum but just realized the grip frames on the 22/45 are still polymer. I see there are two options on Walther Q4 Steel Frame Another one of Walther’s latest releases was its Q4 steel-framed pistol featuring a 15 round capacity. Glock, for example, has been making guns with polymer frames since 1982. 45 ACP pistol. Common alloys of aluminum are 6061 and 7075. The Ruger LCR consists of three modular subcomponents: The upper frame assembly is an aluminum forging that Because it's a polymer, the flex factor is built in, and they will often go many more rounds than comparable steel or aluminum frame guns. Q&A [deleted] • You’re thinking of the frame and it’s really not a factor. Choose Aluminium when: High strength The aluminum frame on the blue version won't rust but the barrel and receiver will and will require more maintenance. Polymer - lower weight Metal w/ elfman trigger = 18. Admittedly, I generally lean towards heavier metal guns as they are more forgiving to shoot. With a polymer frame, having a polymer shoe feels too toy-like, imo. I’m incredibly torn. They said they use 7075 aluminum alloy. In this video, we're doing a review of all 4 and talking about which one we pref Polymer vs Steel & Aluminum frames. We'll cover how to tell a good frame from a bad one, polymer vs. More than most shooters will ever do. The extra weight isn't an issue for me but Ruger now offers a Distributor Special (model 60163) with a My old boss used to say if he ever wore an aluminum frame out he'd consider it an accomplishment and hang it on the wall. Or maybe not; I'm just spitballing here. Since then, I’ve owned (and carried) numerous aluminum frame handguns, including a Walther P-38, and others. AGPDFAXJ4CV6QZMOU4DG5C5IGXTA/BATWYLM7HJYKSee our full shows on CarbonTV! http I know that polymer has its place in the market and currently rules the roost. Reply Opposite_Diamond_239 Combat Machines are legendary despite being nylon frames. Jump to Latest Glocktalk is a forum community dedicated to Glock enthusiasts. Polymer frame pistols are the King of the Mountain; there is no denying it. Jump to Latest 1. e. You could ask/search over on the Sig reddit for polymer grip module vs AXG (aluminum) grip modules. It doesn't feel like a heavy all-steel gun if that's what OP is looking for, and I imagine the recoil impulse is more like that of a polymer gun than a steel pistol. aluminum 80 percent lowers: Cost The idea of building an AR-15 at home with an 80% lower was born by two principles: Convenience and cost. The person on the phone also stated that they get Polymer is not a deal-killer with me, but I personally don't like it. That said if you plan on also shooting the gun a lot, go with steel. 805 oz 4. Use aluminium vs polymer lower receivers as another example; When push comes to shove, By your logic, you better not be using a Glock or any other wunder 9 polymer frame pistol. 156 posts · Joined 2012 Add to quote; Only show this user #1 · Mar 29, 2017. Aluminum badminton rackets are traditional and classic. I would have thought by now, aluminum frame handguns were We tested out 4 different frames for the Sig P365. Now seeing a polymer Factors Influencing Material Selection: 1. Is the softer perceived recoil of polymer just me? Does the heavy steel grip feel too heavy? I know I read people "learned" to like them? I. I carry polymer and all metal firearms, both are fine. The Sig P320 X5 is very well made and holds a special place to me. Polymer frames have been the norm since at least the late 1990's. If there were an issue with polymer frames failing early it would be common knowledge. Any differences between the 2 frames such as frame I'd still wait. While clearing Debris fron Ground Zero back in September/October 2001, we found a lot of Burned up Pistols and Revolvers. Now for the million-dollar question: Are polymer electrolytic capacitors or traditional electrolytic capacitors the better option for engineers? The You’re making some dumb assumptions about polymer guns, if they were so fragile police wouldn’t almost exclusively carry polymer frame Glocks and M&P’s nor would the military have switched over to polymer Sig pistols. Reply reply Maleficent-Street195 • Polymer vs. CNC H&K has a small lineup, so maybe polymer frames are more efficient for larger runs. He had a personal gun that he cherished and carried everyday. Jason_G: Thank you for you support. These critical points include the stock, the pistol grip, and Polymer frame vs aluminum frame vs SS frame. STI made aluminum frames for years and I don't remember reports of them failing. Share The only problem I've had with the plastic C-More is the frame will crack between the windage adjusting screw and the screw that locks it in place. 32 acp, amazingly accurate for I never had a problem with the aluminum frame. It's an aluminum officers MSH that I can't find. 755 oz Polymer e/OEM trigger = 13. You guys that have an aluminum module, is it noticeably better from a recoil perspective? In theory, Iv tried the xl frame, xl stippled frame, xl Wilson combat (second best), macro frame, stipple macro frame, and a Aluminum vs Graphite Badminton Racket FAQs. Make Mine Metal: The Alloy-Frame Aluminum vs Polymer Apex Trigger? I had done some research into the Apex flat triggers about a year ago when I bought my M&P M2. Heat can warp the keyboard areas and push the keys up on the plastic models. Steel guns were not melted, but some frames were distorted from the heat of the fires. Glocks are reliable (Polymer), so are Sig P226’s (Aluminum Frame). Under this circumstance, aluminum and titanium have gained a lot of popularity due to their lightweight and high-strength features in a wide variety of industries, especially Choosing between aluminum vs. The Performance Duty Pistol (PDP) series from Walther Arms has grown to include several options, with frames available in both polymer and metal. I would agree with them that areas like the holes for the slide stop on an aluminum frame are going to take a lot of use before they fail. Aluminum VS Polymer Rail Segments? Jump to Latest 28K views 20 replies 9 participants last post by Notrighty Mar 5, 2022. FYI aluminium ( for the uk guys) My advice is, if you are going with a polymer frame pistol, select one that has metal inserts on the rails. Curiously, and don't shoot the messenger, the light weight Wilson I have that shows the least wear with significant amounts of shooting is my Polymer frame Spec Ops 9. A polymer lower will always retain it's color if it's scratched and will always be comfortable to the touch - never freezing cold or too hot to touch. What I can tell you is that polymer saves a tremendous amount of weight over steel. The grip design is almost always better with metal. 25in at the store. have an SVI Frame & Slide to build a sight tracker. Powder Coated What's the Difference? Its lightweight and strong properties make it ideal for structural components, window frames, and heat sinks. 2 Plastic and 2 Aluminum. The Polymer frames are significantly cheaper to produce than steel or aluminum frames and that cost gets passed on. Manufacturing processes also differ between the two. They are high strength, high stiffness and weight of materials. Based on the customer feedback and months of research and development, the SS80 is made with a much stronger and more durable nylon/polymer blend that is similar to the original 43 but actually dampens felt recoil and provides even better reliability. I’ve heard the polymer flexes and is off balance but Advertisement In terms of dollars spent, you won't see me blowing $3400 on a Kobra Carry LW, a NHC Border Special with a $200 aluminum frame "upgrade," etc. Reply reply I am not quite out of the polymer pistol game. But another somewhat underappreciated factor is how Also, definitely aluminum over polymer. Polymer Slide on a pistol/handgun? Controversial. I don't know anything about aluminum vs polymer, really. Find out they key differences in metal framed vs polymer framed handguns from first hand experience to learn which one is right for your needs! Compared to aluminum, steel, or titanium frames, polymer does have a bit of give. By KOBGT December 15, 2014 in Open Pistols. The aluminum should make the laptop lighter if comparing the same models. Let’s hear some first hand experience, which do you prefer after having tried both, and But I wanted to address your question of the polymer vs. That being said I don't know how anyone can draw the conclusion that polymer is more durable. I prefer that to be a metal framed semi or j frame revolver. They both feel so good. They are crazy light and easy to carry, either concealed or open. Aluminum and alloys are much more durable than Aluminum is much lighter than steel and almost as durable. Also it's super cheap. speedracer5050 August 4, For AIWB carry I can't tell the difference between my Sig P226 with no attachments that has an aluminum frame vs my steel frame Staccato P with a 509T and X300. Old or not, who cares. The aluminum grip doesn't flex like a polymer will nor does it have the strength of steel. The recoil is next to nothing compared to the S&W polymer. Personally I think Beretta did the right thing by choosing to go with an aluminum alloy frame. Comparison of Polymer vs. Aluminum grip module vs Polymer . N. The metal just looks so nice. I have my Ruger American but other than the frame, it is all steel. A Find the gear we use and approve of: https://www. Ruger finally did When looking at heavier steel-framed handguns vs. The Factory G43 Frame. I shoot very well with aluminum grips and maintain a score that awards me a shooting metal at work, but I also shoot very well with the polymer grip and what I carry for work and for EDC. And steel has a higher chance of rusting. July 21, 2023 August 6, 2020 by Rod. I keep holding the metal 2. Pros Of A Polymer Frame. I mean pick your poison here. Your frame might not outlive the other parts but it will outlive you. Im talking long term though. All should be an alloy, as it’s stronger. The frame cracked and he's sworn off aluminum frames for good. Jump to Latest 3. This gun was machined from solid steel billet for reduced recoil and does not have an external safety you what is the consensus on non-steel (i. A Rock Island 1911 GI . 0 and 2. I like my P-01, but I'm wondering why OP is specifically requesting a metal frame. One is the polymer-frame handgun that the accompanying review focuses on, and the second is nearly identical, except that its frame is rendered in aluminum alloy. Which to me is a good thing. 321 posts · Joined 2009 Add to quote; Only show this user #1 · Aug 17, 2009. <they sold for 185. An aluminum frame will help substantially with keeping the weight down, as there is a lot of metal on a 2011 frame. The MKIV 22/45 is a plastic frame. I'm considering getting a new mark 4 target gun and debating between the blued aluminum frame versus the heavier SS frame. Jump to Latest 2. 2K views 5 replies 3 participants last post by heavyduty Apr 12, 2018. 0 Metal Competitor with their new aluminum frame. 3K views 2 replies 3 participants last post by Dooley Mar 29, 2017. I don't have a MKIV but I do have several MKII's. I just picked up a great deal on a new SIG P226, aluminum frame for Polymer in firearms is not new. The MKIV frame has either aluminum or stainless steel. I’d take a steel or aluminum frame over a polymer any dayit’s just whatever is the most comfortable/easy to carry for me that I’m positive will go bang every time. Apparently SIG has figured out using stainless (slide) and aluminum alloy (frame) together. The aluminum frame p-01 is so light, it's pretty similar in weight to a similar sized polymer gun. When folks first encountered them in the 1970s and Don't get scratched up and go shiny on you like aluminum; Aluminum rails: Are stronger and more trustworthy when attaching a sling point or vertical grip; Cost more; Are slightly heavier (no biggie on short rails) Will scratch up and be shiny aluminum; There are probably more pros and cons for each, but that's the only gripes I've had with each Metal frame vs Polymer frame. Pick what you like, there are good serviceable guns out there with polymer, steel, and aluminum frames. The Plastic framed guns frames were totally Melted, as were some Aluminum framed guns. Between that and other variables in those grips that are hard to adjust for in testing, like surface aggressiveness or different ergonomic shapes, I haven't bothered to even consider the polymer. JGreen Discussion starter. Weight Considerations: Choose PC/ABS when: Weight reduction is a critical factor, such as in automotive interiors and certain consumer goods. I love both. Since then, polymers have gotten lighter, AR-15 Lower Receiver Aluminum Vs Polymer – If trends from another slide mounted optic, minor pf division mean anything, the real question is aluminum vs steel. Get a Kimber, a Sig, or better yet, a S&W with a scandium enhanced aluminum frame. vinyl windows for your replacement project can be tough. We’ll compare the weight, durability, handling, efficiency, comfort, cost, longevity, and more to help you decide which frame material is best for your Metal framed hammer fired cz pistols have better trigger pull than the p series polymer Hammer fired because of steel rubbing on steel parts being smoother than steel rubbing on polymer parts, at least I think that's why. : Carbon fiber is the purest carbon type, with its atoms in large SS80 Upgrades vs. It’s been around for a couple hundred years and started coming into general use in the early 1900s. The greatest threat to polymer frame guns is impact, and according to a former Israeli armorer I met, after decades of exposure to the sun, the polymer will become less ductile and eventually break. It is getting harder to find metal frame guns these days as everybody is going to polymer. I would buy the metal one. amazon. I can't remember what my first I own and like both. Dave T: A commander has a full size frame. I don’t think any frame is made of pure aluminum. Here are the pros and cons of each. For rifles, it's kind of a gamble as it leaves an ongoing A pistol's frame can change your pistol's customization options, how comfortable it is to carry, and how fast you shoot accurately. The Edge is good though. Which should you choose? The old polymer frame version or the new metal frame? Both are M2. account. I just like the feeling of the polymer grip much better. I prefer the Polymer frame of a MKII 22/45 over any other Form, fit to my hand is perfect. Nouseforaname Discussion starter. polymer, you’ll find that polymer pistols can feel top-heavy when compared to the balance of a metal frame. 119 posts · Joined 2014 Add to quote; Only show this user #1 · Mar 4, 2015 (Edited Aluminum vs Polymer frame. This makes them lighter and easier to carry for longer with less fatigue. The thing that sucks about aluminum alloy is its much more susceptible to cracking from stress/fatigue. Since you’ve already decided on an M&P, all you need to know is polymer vs aluminum. There are a few complaints about the Y540 deck due to heat issues. Powder Coated surfaces are often used in architectural applications, such as building facades, railings, and furniture. The polymer frames are a bit better but not as much as I would have thought. Should give you a good idea of what to expect Browning 1911-22 Aluminum vs Polymer frame. metal pistol frames, and the Would you rate it as better than polymer, but not as good as all metal frames, or does it approximate the feel and quality of all metal frames? I just purchased a S&W M&P PC 2. Polymer Versus Aluminum HandguardsThe points where your firearm make contact with your body are crucially important for comfortable, accurate, and effective shooting. 25 yards down range my p-07, sp01 and shadow 2 do the same 2 inch groups in my hands not using a rest, rapid fire the metal frames are better for follow up shots. Being metal, it's a different feel loading in mags as there's metal on metal contact. New to 2011s so trying to learn. My Beretta 380 has an aluminum frame, and my Kahrs have the steel frame. 00 retail but scalped for 350. Depending on the model and type of metal frame, metal can change the overall balance and heft of the pistol, something that translates to how the firearm Aluminum/alloy pistol frames are lighter than steel and comparable in weight to polymer frames. Dave T: UPDATE I found on the site where it says Available in aluminum But I had to look a close. Posted: 3/16/2020 2:20:06 AM EST Aluminium vs. What are your thoughts on the durability of the polymer The video of aluminum vs. An old man at the lgs builds 1911's. There will always be time to add plastics later. Sm3lliot Discussion starter. 5 posts • Page 1 of 1. Brantley Merriam, offers insights into which material makes the most sense. They always had a lower take rate because of their competition focus but as long as they offered them I'm sure there are a ton of them out there. All newer SIG slides are stainless steel. 76 posts · Joined 2011 Add to quote; Only show this user #1 · Jan 3, 2017. Then came aluminum. I've had a few pistols (namely Kahr, but not exclusively) that tend to shave polymer off the rails with breaking in. The aluminum frames are going ~90,000 rounds or more, it's more often that not that it's the slide that fails. . 0 polymer full size 4. This guide outlines the pros and cons of carbon vs aluminum bike frames. There are some differences between them Considering I want the C2 to be my "do it all" gun, what are your thoughts with the aluminum frame? Here's the research I did: Called Staccato. Much easier to re align on target for the next shot also. Long term, the aluminum should retain the form better than the plastic. Aluminum VS. There are many advantages to purchasing aluminum frames. 0 from the Smith & Wesson M&P line of 9mm and both are the Full Most of the semiautomatic pistols I have been exposed to, I dare say perhaps all of them, have had polymer or alloy frames and friend and get one> or a Model 66 at the same price range. 5” barrel with a 21 round capacity, and very nice sights I can hit anything I Polymer framed pistols can last for a long time since polymer-injected frames can handle the pressure of a handgun being shot tens of thousands of times. So over time, it will fatigue quicker than Really it all comes down to trigger time, but I think I shoot steel or aluminum alloy frames just a bit better than my polymer handguns, though my Walther P99 pistols are damn close. This will be a short article. Polymer is great, but metal-frame handguns are like getting a good handshake. If durability is an issue, spend less, say, no more than $1500. Gun Ergonomics: When you pick up a gun, you’ll first notice how it feels in your hand. M. Your A pistol's frame can change your pistol's customization options, how comfortable it is to carry, and how fast you shoot accurately. Traditional Aluminum Electrolytic Capacitors. I think the 1st time gun buyer, even if they rent some pistols first, which from my own experience most do not, are not going to be looking at a relatively expensive, metal framed gun and by and large will not be aware of the benefits of an all metal gun until Steel Frame VS Polymer regarding recoil. I don’t know what SIG uses. Pros and Cons of Polymer-Framed Handguns As we established earlier, polymer-framed handguns are very light. Old. 95 oz difference This is not exact as both these lowers have heavily molded Magpul grips that might have different weights. Gear Review: Mesa Tactical shotgun Aluminum vs Polymer Cmore Aluminum vs Polymer Cmore. Once you're out of the dollar store stuff, either one can be quite useable You still have a steel frame no matter which grip you used. But I am curious. For M&P®s, I've been going back and forth between going with an aluminum grip module or sticking with the plastic variant for an upcoming build. Come join the discussion about Glock pistols and rifles, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, and more! 21 - Polymer or steel? A long-standing, often heated debate in the industry. All guns that I witnessed were completely Distroyed. I notice this most comparing my VP9 and my Kahr MK9. Lately I’ve been focusing my efforts on shooting both of my full-size Walther PDPs, the 5” standard polymer frame gun along with the5” PDP Match Steel Frame. Might have to look at those What feels comfortable in your hands. For over twenty years, aluminum was the go-to lightweight metal for handgun frame manufacturing. 00 as well> Aluminum frame guns were the rage as well. polymer lowers when subjected to deflection testing is an obvious attempt to confuse people. Jump to Latest (CZ 75C clone) and it also has the aluminum frame and the steel slide like your P-120. Is the aluminum-framed M&P better than the polymer-framed? Read a full review and comparison of Smith & Wesson's metal series. What should have been tested is the LOAD that the lowers can withstand before failure. 0, but couldn’t bring myself to spend that much money on the aluminum trigger. He's built 100's over the years. YMMV. polymer plastic, composite/g10, aluminum, etc)? i'm generally a steel proponent (at least when it comes to 1911s), but non the less it makes me wonder how these alternatives These three polymer-frame revolvers obviously share similarities, but each has its own unique features. How often do you plan on shooting it. The biggest downside to a metal frame is a heavier gun plain and I sold all of my polymer/aluminum frames (with the exception of my G19 which is my EDC) and just kept my Atlas because it was the best feeling and best shooting (for me) that I experienced. MarkB1 Discussion starter. I keep hearing "metal" is the way, especially for upper end 2011s, but logically polymer makes sense to me. AXG aluminum frame. Alloy is the next best, then fibre-filled polymer, then good aluminium, then steel. com/ideas/amzn1. Here are a few main benefits. Top. Both types of windows are more durable and require less maintenance than wood, and they come at a lower cost than We tested Mesa Tactical's magazine/barrel clamp with an accessory rail, and their popular new Sureshell polymer shotshell carrier, packaged with rails. If you want lighter then do polymer. jqgdd ydgf yffn hzjhht xojctgm xawtr azsbfw gbkbw coydlh wcr